Number
This project examines the extent to which a shared belief in number’s elemental status throughout the Middle Ages inflected how people perceived and interacted with the material world.
Throughout the middle ages, number was understood to be the basis of matter. We get some sense of the implications of this principle in Westminster’s spectacular Cosmati pavement. The riddle-like inscription embedded in the floor renders the age of the primum mobile (i.e., the first or outermost sphere of the heavens) in terms of the combined lifespans of the creatures within its ambit. To find the number, readers must add the age of a hedge to that of a dog, a horse, a man, and so on, to whale and even to world! Number’s power is on show: as quantity, nature’s variety becomes commensurate, comparable and tractable; its divine origin apparent.
According to the Bible, Creation was the act of a mathematically minded God who made all things by ‘measure, number and weight’ (Ws 11:21). This well-worn passage from Scripture was read alongside Plato’s Timaeus, a dialogue on the cosmos that underpinned much medieval and early modern science. According to these sources and the pavement, numeric qualities inhere in all bodies—whether plant or animal, natural or manmade, living or inanimate—and constitute immutable truths. Humans were thought to be specially equipped to detect such truths. Plato maintained that the ‘supreme good’ of vision was the ability ‘to denumerate’ (dinumerare in the Latin translation), meaning to discern number, count or calculate (47a). For the influential Saint Augustine, mathematical and artistic form was enmeshed. He wrote, ‘Artisans have numbers in their craft which they apply to their works . . . whatever delights you in a body and entices your bodily senses is full of number’ (De libero arbitrio 2.16.42). Here, the frisson of aesthetic pleasure arises from number’s sensation, its denumeration.
This project examines the extent to which shared belief in number’s elemental status inflected how people perceived and interacted with the material world. I am working on a book tentatively titled Numeracy and Visuality in the Central Middle Ages, that reconstructs numeric study circa 1000, and traces its effects on representation in Europe, especially in religious art and architecture. The latter offer a fresh view of medieval mathematics, emphasizing number as an agent of faith, beauty and play.
Publications
‘The Geometry of Jesus, c. 1000’ [expected completion 2024]
Number and Visuality in the Central Middle Ages [expected completion 2025]
‘Grid Space in Boethius’s On Arithmetic’, in Jeffrey Hamburger, David Roxburgh and Linda Safran (eds.), Diagram Paradigm: Byzantium, the Islamic World, and the Latin West (Washington, DC: Dumbarton Oaks Publications, 2022).
‘Romanesque Abstraction and the “Unconditionally Two-Dimensional Surface”’, in Elina Gertsman (ed.), Abstraction in Medieval Art: Beyond the Ornament (Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press, 2021).
‘Imaging and Imagining Solidity’, in Beatrice Kitzinger and Joshua O’Driscoll (eds.), After the Carolingians: Re-Defining Manuscript Illumination in the 10th and 11th Centuries (Boston: De Gruyter, 2019), 86–117.
‘Picturing as Practice: Placing a Square above a Square in the Central Middle Ages’, in Anthony Grafton and Glenn Most (eds.), Canonical Texts and Scholarly Practices: A Global Comparative Approach (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2016), 200–23.
‘Picturing Number in the Central Middle Ages’ (PhD, University of Michigan, Fall 2015).
Presentations
‘The Medieval Meander: Depicting Depth and the Corporeity of Paint’
Image, Ornament, Matter: An International Symposium on Their Limits and Intersections in the History of Art, University of Florida, 12–13 April 2019
‘The Grammar of Time’
The Monastic Experience of Time, Durham University, 18–19 April 2019
‘Medieval Corporeity’
Thinking Materially, Medieval Research Seminar, Cambridge University, 11 October 2018
‘Diagrams and Dinumeratio in Medieval Europe’
The Diagram Paradigm: Byzantium, the Latin West, and the Islamic World, Dumbarton Oaks, 20–21 April 2018
‘Romanesque Abstraction and the “Unconditionally Two-Dimensional Surface”’
Fifth Annual Symposium on Medieval and Renaissance Studies, Saint Louis University, 19–21 June 2017
‘Gospel Books as Geometric Argument, c. 1000’Mittelalterliche Bildgeometrie, Technische Universität and Staatlichen Kunstsammlungen Dresden, 23–25 November 2016
‘“Between Angels and Humans”: Engraving in the Central Middle Ages’
International Congress on Medieval Studies, Western Michigan University, 12–15 May 2016
‘Christ × Christ × Christ’
History of Science Society Annual Meeting, 19–22 November 2015
‘Numeracy and Representation around the Year 1000’
Medieval Art History after the Interdisciplinary Turn, University of Notre Dame, 28–29 March 2014
‘Mathematics in the Margins’
Commentary Cultures: Technologies of Medieval Reading, Zukunftsphilologie, Freie Universitaet Berlin, 16–17 May 2013
‘Figura, Forma, Pictura: A Study in Terms’
Maps and Diagrams in Medieval Art, Index of Christian Art, Princeton University, 15–16 March 2013
Symposia, Workshops & Conference Sessions
Circular Thinking: The Drawing Compass as a Premodern Tool of Creation in Europe (co-organiser with Sarah Griffin)
The Warburg Institute, School of Advanced Study, University of London, 10–11 June 2021
‘The Elements and Elementality in Art of the Premodern World’ (co-chair with Michelle McCoy)
College Art Association, 21–24 February 2018
Time Bound: A Workshop on Computus in Medieval Books (co-organiser with Danielle Joyner)
University of Rochester, 15 November 2019
Southern Methodist University, 10 November 2017
The Materiality of Scientific Knowledge (discussant & co-organizer with Dahlia Porter, et al.)
Kislak Center, University of Pennsylvania, 30 September–1 October 2016
Folding
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Habitasse platea dictumst quisque sagittis. Quisque id diam vel quam elementum pulvinar etiam non.
I am completing an article on the semantics of folding in late medieval England that centres on a fourteenth-century almanac, the remarkable Oxford, Bodleian Library, Rawlinson D. 939. The manuscript comprises six oblong parchment sheets. Each is folded first lengthwise to form a narrow strip and then again, in a zig-zag or accordion pattern to create a palm-sized packet. Folded, Rawl. D. 939 can be paged through like a codex. But, like a pop-up book, its pages open, revealing an array of calendrical, chronological, devotional, medical, economic and prognostic material. Cuts in the parchment allow a viewer to access information on the inside without unfolding an entire sheet. If we were to fully unfold the manuscript and place its sheets end-to-end, it would stretch an astonishing 2.5 meters. Folded, it measures 14 x 11 cm—compact, but no more so than many almanac codices, which measure on average around 15 x 10 cm, making them just as portable. Given this, I am curious why a thing like Rawl. D. 939 was created and believe the answer to that question lies in a better understanding of, on the one hand, the expressive pressures that time-related content put on the codex, and, on the other, of the formal and relational possibilities folding afforded.
I am also collaborating with Sarah Griffin and Kathleen Doyle on a catalogue of all the European concertina-fold almanacs. Sarah is curating an exhibition at Lambeth Palace Library February–May 2025 that will feature many English examples, including parts of Rawlinson D 939. If you want to be kept in the loop about this work enter your email below.
Publications
with Sarah Griffin and Kathleen Doyle. Concertina-Fold Almanacs: A Catalogue [expected completion 2024]
‘A Wrinkle in Time: The Structural Significance of a Fourteenth-Century Folded Almanac’ [expected completion 2024]
Nos. 164–5, in Lisa Fagin Davis et al. (eds.), Beyond Words: Illuminated Manuscripts in Boston Collections (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2016), 201–206.
‘Making Knowledge Portable: The Zodiac Man, in the Context of Folded Medical Almanacs‘ (MA, The Courtauld Institute, 2007).
Presentations
‘A Wrinkle in Time: The Structural Significance of a Concertina-Fold Almanac’
Kress Foundation Art of the European Book Lecture, Rare Book School, University of Virginia, 25 July 2022
with Kathleen Doyle and Sarah M. Griffin, ‘Time Unfolded: Cataloguing Concertina-Fold Almanacs’
The Book Print Initiative, School of Advanced Study, University of London, 24 February 2022
with Sarah Griffin, ‘Time Unfolded: The Rashleigh Calendar and Medieval Concertina-Fold Almanacs’
Kresen Kernow (‘Cornwall Centre’), 13 January 2022
‘A Wrinkle in Time: Fold and Form in a 14th-century Computus Manuscript’
Hooking Up, Schoenberg Symposium of Manuscript Studies in the Digital Age, University of Pennsylvania, 21–23 November 2019
‘“Walking 500 Winters”: Picturing the Time between Planets in a Folded Almanac’
Medieval Academy of America Annual Meeting, 12–14 February 2015
Conference Sessions
‘The Concertina-Fold Book, Across Premodern Cultures’ (Co-organiser with Sarah Griffin)
International Medieval Congress, University of Leeds, 5 July 2023. Supported by an ICMA Kress Travel Grant SoFCB Funds
Tablet Weaving
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Habitasse platea dictumst quisque sagittis. Quisque id diam vel quam elementum pulvinar etiam non.
While conducting research on numeracy, I began to look more closely at tablet weaving. It is, as its name implies, a loomless technique in which small tablets of bone, wood or similar material, pierced and threaded, are turned to twist strands of silk or wool into ‘narrow wares’ such as belts, girdles, pouches and colourful bands for edging garments. In premodern Europe, it was work done entirely (we think) by women. I see it as a form of tacit mathematical expression and am beginning to explore the effects of its practice on the devotional and practical economies of female communities, both lay and monastic. Raw materials were frequently obtained in exchange for prayers that accompanied the weaving process. Key clerical vestments including the liturgical girdle, stole, pallium and maniple were often tablet woven as were some of the most eye-catching elements of royal costumes. Women were sometimes granted exclusive rights for the supply and repair of these objects, which, to judge from extant pieces that carry the names and pictures of their makers, served as sites for personal promotion and even as surrogates, entering spaces and participating in rites off-limits to their human counterparts.
Related Publications
‘Patterns of Experience: Communicating Textile Knowledge at Sankt Klara, Nuremberg’. [expected publication, 2023]
Related Presentations
’Writing Weaving in Nuremberg, c. 1500’
BAA lecture, 2 March 2022
‘Twisted Piety: Tablet Weaving at the Convent of Sankt Klara, Nuremberg, c. 1500’
UEA World Art Research Seminar, 9 February 2022
‘Meditation, Quantification and Tablet Weaving in Premodern Europe’
The Contemplative Clinic, The Warburg Institute, School of Advanced Study, University of London, 16 September 2019
Image of St Ulrich’s Maniple, Basilika St Ulrich und St Afra (Augsburg, DE) from Coatsworth, Elizabeth and Gale R. Owen-Crocker, eds. Clothing the Past: Surviving Garments from Early Medieval to Early Modern Western Europe. Leiden: Brill, 2018. Page 332.